I caught a late screening of A Mighty Wind this Saturday and can’t tell you how pleased I was. For the record, I am not a big fan of Christopher Guest’s movies. Didn’t care for Waiting for Guffman, couldn’t stand Best in Show. Both of them I found only fitfully funny, a big laugh followed by a long period of uncomfortable silence. It’s exactly how I normally feel in the presence of something that could be funny if the person telling the joke wasn’t, at heart, an asshole.
In Guffman and Show, I got the sense Christopher Guest didn’t think much of his characters. Sure, he found their silly preoccupations (dog shows, community theatre) cute, comically, a good mine. Genially obsessive people can be a hoot if left to their own devices. I just wanted Guest to move the fuck out of the way and let that happan.
These characters were plenty hilarious on their own. Instead, he gives each just enough time to make an ass of themselves and then moves on the next one. The result: None of them develop enough to be funny as people, but instead are funny as cultural-types: community theatre devotees, dog show enthusiasts, small towners, the unironic. The message: People who are crazy about community theatre and dog shows are funny because their concerns are petty and stupid compared to ours.
I don’t find that funny, just mean.
The spiritual ancestor to all these films is of course,This is Spinal Tap (which was made by Rob Reiner, not Guest. Guest played the dim guitarist who insisted his speakers cold go up to 11.), made in 1984. Its hilarity (still, after about 63 viewings) eminates from how completely convinced this terrible band of heavy metal has-beens remain about their own talent and importance, how hard they work at being rock stars when they so clearly aren’t anymore. Wind pulls the same trick yet but with a lighter touch. The three 60’s folk acts who have assembled for a tribute concert in the present day still float on a raft of their own self-importance. Yet unlike the heavy-metalers who refuse to believe they’re careers have been cast out to sea (Reiner clearly thinks they are nimrods), the three folk acts either have no interest in nostolgia, know folk ain’t coming back and are a little grumpy about it, or are perfectly context to gut folk and parade around in the carcass for a few bucks. The comedy then comes from watching them poke at, bite, or run away from their own irrelevence. It’s got vulnerability and a heart, which makes me laugh even more.
There are some great jokes, and Guest and Co. earn them all (Harry Shearer and bandmates talking about how they had to add the holes to their first records is just a riot) by creating funny characters in a vaguely sad situation and then letting them be. Instead of the cheap, shooting gallery humor of Waiting for Guffman and Best in Show, A Mighty Wind works by laying it on gently rather than being nasty for its own sake.